Foreign visitors to England are generally impressed not only by Buckingham
Palace and buttery scones, but also by the high quality of British television.
In-depth, non-commercial TV in the UK is enabled
primarily by massive public
funding of the British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC), which receives about £3
billion ($5.5 billion) in public tax money a year. The BBC's highly
influential international branch ― BBC World Service ― draws from these
funds to bring their programming to no less than 152 countries worldwide.
The generous BBC budget and lack of commercial pressure allow it to broadcast
one type of content ― documentary films ― that has unique potential to add
quality
context to day-to-day news.
But a new, in-depth study released by London attorney Trevor Asserson's bbcwatch indicates that the BBC has used their documentary
films on world events not to provide essential, impartial news context, but
rather as a platform for an unremitting ideological mission: 'a campaign to vilify
Israel.'
Of the seventeen documentary programs the BBC produced on Israel over the past
four years, only
one presented Israel in a positive light; the other sixteen were
overwhelmingly pro-Palestinian, casting Israel as a brutal aggressor
nation.
These programs are generally well-advertised several days
beforehand, and are typically broadcast at peak viewing times.
Here are just a few of the anti-Israel documentaries aired by the BBC recently, with bbcwatch's comments:
● The Ugly War: Children of Vengeance
(2/24/02) : The hidden world of Palestinian terrorists (referred to throughout
as 'militias' and 'martyrs'). "Terrorist bombings of Israeli civilians are
painted as an entirely legitimate activity, almost heroic."
●
Israel's Secret Weapon (4/30/03) : Looks
at the build-up of Israel's nuclear weapons program.
The documentary begins by asking the ominous
questions "Which
country in the Middle East has undeclared nuclear weapons?"
"Which
country in the Middle East has undeclared biological and chemical capabilities?"
and "Which country in the Middle East has no outside inspections?"
(see BBC promo at right)
The
documentary was broadcast shortly after the Iraq war had ended. "The
inference behind these opening remarks, which is repeated throughout the film,
is that Israel would have been a more appropriate target than Iraq for the
coalition forces to attack."
● Suicide Killers: Everyman
(4/3/02) : The psychology and ideology of the suicide bomber worldwide. "One is
made to feel sorry for and sympathetic with the Palestinian suicide bomber who
says he 'loved life and wanted to be a doctor. Occupation has murdered my
dreams.'"
● The
War Party (5/18/03) : A group of conservative Washington
politicians ― the 'neocons' ―are
depicted as dangerous or even evil. "This is a highly sensitive issue," the
narrator says, but "the majority of neo-conservatives have been and remain
Jewish...are strongly pro-Zionist and want to topple regimes in the
Middle East to help Israel..." Says bbcwatch, "It is hard to find clear blue
water between these theories and the Protocols of the Elders of Zion."
● Days That
Shook the World: Birth of Israel (1/28/04) : History of the
birth of Israel, told partially through the eyes of an imaginary pair of
Palestinian brothers. Presents "the fundamental unfairness underpinning the
existence of the Jewish state. It is suggested that the Jews wish to
expel all the Palestinians," conveniently ignoring the fact that the Jews
accepted the 1947 UN partition plan, while the Arabs rejected it.
* *
*
As continually noted by HonestReporting (and by journalist
Tom
Gross in a recent article), these BBC documentaries are part of a
deep-seated, institutional anti-Israel bias, a culture that drove the senior
BBC Arabic Service correspondent in Gaza,
Fayad Abu Shamala, to announce at a Hamas rally in May 2001 that
journalists and media organizations, including the BBC, are "waging the
campaign shoulder-to-shoulder together with the Palestinian people."
Indeed, the bbcwatch report found that despite
the BBC's legal obligation from its charter to "provide a properly
balanced service consisting of a wide range of subject matter," ensuring that
"no significant strand of thought should go unreflected or underrepresented,"
the BBC actually devotes a highly disproportionate amount of space to the
Israeli/Palestinian in general, and to the Palestinian point-of-view in
particular. This further strengthens what viewers sense from any
documentary on its own ― the BBC has an overriding, active agenda to indict
Israel not only for local problems, but for much of the world's ills.
Moreover, the reputation and
broad reach of the BBC ensure
the immense and potentially dangerous influence of
its material, fanning the flames of worldwide anti-Semitism. Reports
bbcwatch: "It is not fanciful to contemplate that, by
portraying Israel in an unnecessarily negative light, the BBC might itself
unwittingly encourage aggression not only against Israelis, but also against
UK Jewish citizens."
ACTION ITEMS:
It is high time that the BBC be forced to compete in the open
marketplace like all other news agencies. In that scenario, the
general public could demand journalistic integrity from the BBC front
office, editors and reporters, ensuring that BBC documentaries show
both sides of the Mideast conflict, and putting an end to the
BBC's relentless campaign to vilify the State of Israel.
bbcwatch laments the fact that the BBC has been
almost completely non-responsive to their previous critiques.
Fortunately, however, there's another path of action ― the BBC's Royal
Charter and funding are presently under British governmental review.
HonestReporting encourages subscribers to support the cancellation or
non-renewal of the charter by writing to UK Culture Secretary Tessa
Jowell, bringing bbcwatch's latest report to Ms. Jowell's attention as
her department considers the ongoing public funding of the BBC.
Send email to Tessa Jowell at:
tessa.jowell@culture.gsi.gov.uk
If you'd prefer to comment directly to the BBC,
write BBC Director General Mark Thompson:
mark.thompson@bbc.co.uk
Subscribers are encouraged to read the full
bbcwatch report, and their other three in-depth reports, on the
bbcwatch website.
Thank you for your ongoing support in the battle
against media bias.
HonestReporting